English Muffin Pizza in the Air Fryer

English muffin pizza is the fastest kid-friendly mini pizza, and the air fryer makes the base crisp instead of chewy. Air fryer English muffin pizza takes about 7 minutes per batch at 375 °F, with nooks that hold the sauce and cheese that bubbles and browns at the edges. Here are the times, the right order of steps and a few topping ideas.

Jump to recipe
Four English muffin mini pizzas with melted mozzarella and pepperoni on a plate
Temperature
375°F190 °C
Total time
24min
Prep time
10min
Servings
4
Per serving
310kcal

Why the air fryer works for English muffin pizza

An English muffin is an almost ideal tiny pizza crust. The cut side is full of nooks that catch sauce and cheese, and the bread is sturdy enough to carry toppings without collapsing. What a muffin does not do well is stay crisp. In a toaster oven or microwave, the base steams and turns chewy. In an air fryer, the fan dries the surface of the bread while it heats the cheese, so the base stays crunchy and the top browns at the edges.

The size is also a perfect match for a basket. Four halves fit in most 5 qt air fryers in a single layer, and the whole pizza is hot in about 7 minutes. That makes the dish good for after-school snacks, quick lunches and last-minute game day appetizers.

How to make English muffin pizza in the air fryer

Tap a time to start a timer.

  1. Preheat Preheat the air fryer to 375 °F for .
  2. Toast the muffins Mist the cut sides of 4 muffin halves lightly with oil. Place them in the basket, cut side up, and cook for . This dries the surface so the pizza stays crisp.
  3. Top Spread 1 tbsp of pizza sauce on each half and sprinkle with 3 tbsp mozzarella. Add 3 slices of pepperoni to each half and a pinch of Italian seasoning.
  4. Cook Put the topped halves back in the basket in a single layer. Cook for , until the cheese is bubbling and the edges are golden brown.
  5. Repeat Remove the first 4 pizzas and cook the other 4 halves the same way. Let them stand for before serving.

Times and temperatures

English Muffin PizzaTemperatureTime
Classic cheese and pepperoni2 min toast, 5 min topped375 °F (190 °C)7 min
No pre-toastSofter base375 °F (190 °C)5–6 min
From frozen muffins3 min toast, 5 min topped375 °F (190 °C)8 min
Reheat350 °F (180 °C)2–3 min

Times are a guide and depend on the size and wattage of your air fryer. See also air fryer cooking times for all foods.

Tips

  • Toast before topping. Two minutes of dry heat sets the surface. It is the biggest difference between a crisp and a limp mini pizza.
  • Go light on toppings. Three slices of pepperoni and 3 tbsp of cheese per half is plenty. Overloaded halves cook unevenly.
  • Use low-moisture mozzarella. It melts evenly and browns at the edges. Fresh mozzarella is better added in the last minute, and patted dry.

Toppings and kid-friendly ideas

Cheese and pepperoni are the classic combination, but there are many ways to vary it. Try cooked sausage crumbles, diced ham and pineapple, sliced olives, mushrooms, or a thin layer of sliced bell pepper. Raw meat toppings need to be cooked before they go on, since 5 minutes is not enough to cook them through. For a breakfast version, use a spoonful of scrambled eggs, crumbled bacon and cheddar instead of sauce. If you want a larger, thicker pizza, see how to cook pizza in the air fryer.

What to serve with English muffin pizza

A simple salad or raw vegetables with ranch are enough for lunch. For a casual dinner, add air fryer zucchini or green beans on the side.

Storing and reheating

Keep leftover pizzas in a sealed container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. Reheat at 350 °F for 2–3 minutes, until crisp and hot, and 165 °F in the center if there is meat on them. You can also freeze the assembled, uncooked halves on a tray, bag them once solid and cook them from frozen at 350 °F for 8–9 minutes.

Variations

  • Margherita: Use sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella patted dry and basil leaves added after cooking.
  • Veggie: Top with diced bell pepper, mushrooms and onion, sautéed first, so they do not release water.
  • Garlic bread pizza: Brush the muffin halves with garlic butter before toasting and use Italian seasoning on top.

If it does not turn out right

The base is soggy
The muffin was not toasted first or the sauce was thin. Give the cut side 2 minutes of heat alone, and use a thick pizza sauce, about 1 tbsp per half.
The cheese blows off
The fan can move loose shreds. Press the cheese lightly into the sauce and keep the toppings below the rim of the muffin.
The edges burn
Thin muffins brown fast. Lower the heat to 350 °F and add 1 minute, or check after 4 minutes.

Questions and answers

How long do you cook English muffin pizza in the air fryer?

About 7 minutes at 375 °F, made up of 2 minutes of toasting and 5 minutes with toppings. If you skip the toasting step, 5–6 minutes is enough, but the base is softer.

What temperature should English muffin pizza be cooked at in the air fryer?

375 °F is the best balance, because the cheese melts and the muffin crisps at the same pace. At 350 °F, allow 1–2 extra minutes.

Can you make English muffin pizza from frozen muffins?

Yes, but split them while frozen with a fork, toast the cut sides for 3 minutes first, then add the toppings and cook for 5 minutes.

How do you reheat English muffin pizza in the air fryer?

Heat at 350 °F for 2–3 minutes. If the pizza has meat on it, make sure it is hot all the way through, 165 °F.

What did you think of this recipe?

Be the first to rate this recipe.